Blocks
Item
Title
Isn’t this the right project in the wrong location?
Content

This location is widely regarded as one of the best locations for pumped hydro storage in NSW.

Lake Lyell already provides a lower reservoir, a water source, access to transmission infrastructure, good topography, and land already zoned for energy generation.

Title
Will we still be able to use the lake given the change in the water level?
Content

Historically the water level in Lake Lyell fluctuates with the seasons. Regular lake visitors may remember the lake has not always been full of water.  

Prior to 2010 it fluctuated greatly. During the 2006 drought the water levels dropped 20m below full. The new Lake Lyell Hydro facility will see water levels gradually drop over an eight-hour period by around two metres.

Lake Lyell Hydro has committed to making further investment into the Recreation Centre including; new pontoons and swimming areas, and ensuring the boat-ramp is long enough and launch-ready during times when water levels are lower.

Title
Why don’t you just build more grid-scale batteries?
Content

Different technologies play different roles in the broader energy market. Batteries operate over shorter periods of time. Pumped hydro operates over longer periods and are often referred to as long duration storage.

Batteries also have a life span of between 15 to 20 years, wile pumped hydro has a lifespan of 80 to 100 years. This provides greater supply and stability in the system as pumped hydro can provide coverage dyring battery maintenance and vice versa.

Title
Doesn’t it use more energy than it generates?
Content

No energy storage system (including lithium-ion batteries) are 100% efficient. The Lake Lyell Pumped Hydro project will have a round-trip efficiency of around 80% which is as good as lithium-ion batteries, and better than some other emerging storage technologies.

Title
Who owns and maintains the lake?
Content

EnergyAustralia is the owner and operator of the Lake Lyell with responsibility for maintaining Lake Lyell, Thompsons Creek Reservoir, and the Lilyvale Dam, including making significant investments into the dams ongoing compliance, capital works, and operational costs.

EnergyAustralia spends over $2.5 million annually to maintain Lake Lyell.

Lake Lyell is not a naturally formed lake. The dam was built in 1982 by the then NSW Government owned Delta Electricity to supply water for the Mt Piper and Wallerawang Power Stations, The construction of the dam flooded sections of the Coxs River and Farmers Creek, creating Lake Lyell. It operates as part of a connected system of dams, including the Thompson Creek Reservoir and Lake Wallace.

Title
Will the platypus be harmed by the Project?
Content

A Platypus Management Plan is proposed to be developed to help protect the platypus. This Plan will outline measures such as avoiding certain construction activities during the nesting season, inspecting for and relocating platypuses if needed, rehabilitating disturbed areas, and managing water quality with silt curtains. Adaptive measures, developed with experts and First Nations representatives, will be considered if platypus health declines.

Title
What will be done to ensure the Project is implementing the mitigation measures it committed to?
Content

If approved, the Project must comply with the conditions of the approval. As a State Significant Infrastructure (SSI) project, these conditions may require us to prepare things like management plans, monitoring programs and a complaints management system before we start construction. 

The Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure (the Department) oversees all post-approval requirements with other relevant government agencies that have a stake in our Project . The Department will publish copies of our management plans and post-approval decisions on the on the major projects website (Lake Lyell Pumped Hydro Energy Storage | Planning Portal - Department of Planning and Environment), You can access and track progress of the project via this website. 

We will be responsible for:

  • monitoring how we comply to the conditions of approval
  • publicly reporting on any non-compliances
  • undertaking independent environmental audits and investigating complaints. 

Further more, if the project is approved, we will also be required to obtain other approvals, such as an environment protection licence, before we start. 

Title
What percentage of construction workers will be local and how will workers from out-of-town be housed?
Content

We’re committed to maximising local employment. Dedicated training and education programs (including apprenticeships) will upskill workers from Lithgow and surrounding areas, with the Project seeking to employ at least 30% of the total workforce from the local region. While a temporary workforce accommodation facility is needed as part of this Project, workers requiring accommodation for a short period can still secure local accommodation, providing a boost to local motels or short-term rental suppliers. Workers housed at Project’s workers’ accommodation will spend time in the local area and engage in recreational activities, contributing to the local economy.

Title
Have Wiradjuri Traditional Owners been involved in the Project’s Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Assessment?
Content

The project has followed Heritage NSW’s Aboriginal Cultural Heritage Consultation Requirements for Proponents guidelines to the Aboriginal cultural heritage assessment. A total of 19 Registered Aboriginal Parties (RAP) applied in June 2023 to be consulted as part of the Project, and engagement has since grown to 22 active participants including local Wiradjuri Traditional Owners. RAPs have been directly involved in early works surveys, monitoring, artefact identification, cultural values studies, and archaeology, and providing advice on design and cultural site management.

Title
What are the long-term benefits for the community?
Content

Once operational, the Project is expected to inject over $290 million into the regional economy, supporting around 50 ongoing direct and indirect jobs. In addition, the Shared Benefit Program will begin during construction and continue through the first 20 years of operations, supporting community projects and local initiatives. During construction, the project will create more than 650 direct and indirect jobs, including over 40 apprentice positions. These apprentices will complete their qualifications by the time construction finishes, making the project a significant long-term career-building opportunity for local people.

Title
Who did the studies for the Project’s Environmental Impact Statement?
Content

All EIS studies were carried out by independent, qualified experts. The company that led the development of the EIS was EMM Consulting which has been operating for over 15 years.
 

Title
Is the government funding this Project?
Content

In 2022, Lake Lyell Hydro was awarded development funding support under the NSW Government’s Pumped Hydro Recoverable Grants program for feasibility studies only. No further government funding has been provided. The Project is fully owned by a joint venture between EnergyAustralia and EDF power solutions Australia, who are jointly funding ongoing development and, if the project is approved, its final delivery.

Title
Does community feedback influence the Project?
Content

Since 2021 the Project team has been out and about in the community having conversations and hearing your feedback. This engagement has seen over 170 000 interactions with community, which included 36 community events, over 360 phone and email enquiries and 138 online or in-person meetings having taken place.

The following aspects of the Project were influenced by community and stakeholder feedback:

  • Relocating the upper reservoir to reduce visual impacts
  • Proposing an alternative location for worker accommodation
  • Developing a Neighbour Agreement Guide
  • Expanding access to project information via our local HQ, newsletters, and online updates
Title
Will there be any noise and vibration impacts during construction and operation?
Content

During construction, there would be increased traffic noise from construction vehicles travelling on Sir Thomas Mitchell Drive and Magpie Hollow Road. 

Vibration impacts during construction are unlikely, given the relatively large distances between construction areas and the nearest residences.

During construction, it is predicted that noise will exceed the relevant noise criteria at some locations during daytime and nighttime hours, however, no locations are highly noise affected (i.e. experiencing greater than 75 dB).

Operation of the Project would not result in any exceedances in noise levels, vibration or road traffic noise.

Title
Will there be any air quality impacts during construction and operation?
Content

The main impacts to air quality during construction will come from dust from the movement of spoil and diesel fuel use in construction equipment. 

Construction air quality is expected to remain compliant with the NSW Environment Protection Authority’s criteria at all locations.

During operation, the amount of traffic, fuel use and associated air quality emissions will be substantially lower than during the construction.

Title
Were any rare, endangered, or protected species found that could stop or significantly alter the Project?
Content

The construction envelope does not contain any threatened ecological communities, and no
threatened plants were recorded.  Five threatened species were recorded:
− Koala
− South-eastern Glossy Black-Cockatoo
− Gang-gang Cockatoo
− Powerful Owl and Sooty Owl 
− The Purple Copper Butterfly was not recorded but is assumed to be present 
In some cases, there may be impacts to rare and endangered species, however this is unlikely to stop the Project. 

Title
How much land will be cleared for the Project?
Content

It is expected there will be a loss of about 130 hectares of vegetation, of which about 102 hectrates is native vegetation and threatened species habitat. 

Title
How will biodiversity impacts be mitigated or offset?
Content

A Biodiversity Management Plan will be developed to guide the mitigation, management and monitoring of biodiversity and aquatic fauna.  

Offsets are required for direct impacts and would be sought by the Project through a staged offsetting strategy. 

Impact avoidance through design is a key mitigation, this includes:

  • siting of the proposed substation in areas of non-native and highly modified vegetation, where
    possible
  • the choice of the Project location means we do not require a new power transmission line, lower reservoir, water supply pipeline or large new roads/road upgrades 
  • placing stockpiles of excavated materials in low-quality vegetation, where possible 
Title
Can I still use the lake for fishing, swimming, boating and other water-based activities?
Content

Activities such as boating, fishing, and general use of the lake will still be possible. But during construction, there may be temporary changes, for example, how you access the jetty at the Lake Lyell Recreation Park during construction. 

Title
How will lake levels change?
Content

Once operational, the water level will gently rise and fall each day, around 2.5 m over an 8-hour period. During construction, we may see more variation as work progresses. 

Let's stay connected

Sign up for updates, ask a question or have your say.

Subscribe now

 

EnergyAustralia and EDF power solutions Australia recognise that we operate and plan for the energy transition on the traditional Country of the Wiradjuri peoples and we respect and acknowledge their continued connection to Country and culture.